Skip to content
Previous article
Now Reading:
Pinetree's Pumpkin & Squash Puree Recipe

Pinetree's Pumpkin & Squash Puree Recipe

There are many different methods for using the abundance of pumpkins and squash in your garden, just in time for winter. We're thinking soups, sauces, toppings for meat dishes and much more...

Chef Jef shared with us a simple and delectable recipe for a squash puree you'll be eating straight out of the bowl!

When selecting a squash or pumpkin to make your puree from, keep in mind that not all pumpkins and squash are created equal. Small pie pumpkins, such as the Winter Luxury are the perfect choice for a sweet or savory puree. Large Jack-O-Lantern pumpkins (such as the Howden shown below), however, are NOT ideal for creating puree. Pie pumpkins are smaller and more dense with a smooth velvety texture that is fiber free with pure pumpkin flavor. Decorating or Jack-O-Lantern pumpkins like Howden have a bland, watery, fibrous pulp. They can be used but are not optimum for culinary purposes and better serve for decorating carving and livestock feed. The Galeux D' Eysines, Small Sugar, Gold Nugget, and Ebony Acorn squashes are all wonderful choices to create a flavorful puree.

Pumpkins and squash with textA little bit of history on pumpkins and squash before we start! Pumpkins are a fruit (more specifically a berry) that have seeds and pulp that is produced from a single ovary (the female pumpkin flower). Contrary to popular belief, most commercial canned pumpkin is made from winter squash, where squash tends to have a sweeter, stronger flavor that gives the soups, pies, and breads we make with it the flavor we all know and recognize!

The origin of the word 'pumpkin' comes from Greek word 'pepon', meaning large melon, with the French changing to 'pompon' then the British changing it to 'pumpion', and its final name give by the American colonists, in which the meat and seed provided nourishment to colonists and livestock. The original pumpkin pie was the whole pumpkin top was cut off, seeds removed, and then filled with eggs, milk, spices, and honey to be baked in hot ashes. Here is a link to another blogger who tried the original pumpkin pie recipe out and had success! Pumpkins were also used by colonists to make beer. They are native to Central America with oldest evidence of pumpkin seeds dating back to around 5000-7000 BC in Mexico. 1 billion pounds of pumpkin are produced in the US every season. Health benefits include being a high source of A, C, E, and B vitamins, as well as potassium, fiber, and rich in antioxidants.

For this recipe, you'll need these ingredients:
Your selected squash or pumpkin
Olive oil
Garlic (whole cloves)
Fresh thyme
Cream or vegetable/chicken stock
Salt & pepper
A knife suitable for cutting through the thick walls of your squash

cutting board with knife, herbs, milk, butter, and garlic

Cut your pumpkin or squash in half, down the middle from top to bottom.

hands with knife cutting a pumpkin in half on a cutting board

Scoop out the insides, including the seeds and fibrous pulp.

half a pumpkin and bowl with seeds, knife, spoon, on a cutting board

pumpkins cut in half on countertop with knife, spoon, spices, herbs, garlic, butter, on a cutting board

Once you've scooped the insides of your halves, clean them and rub lightly with olive oil. Sprinkle the olive oil coated insides with both salt and pepper.

hands sprinkling salt and pepper on a pumpkin half on a cutting board in kitchen

Select a generous amount of fresh thyme to stuff inside the halves.

hands with fresh thyme adding to a pumpkin half on a cutting board in kitchen

Break off 2-3 cloves of garlic from your bulb and peel off the outermost layers of skin before smashing the cloves with the flat side of your knife. This helps to release some of the flavors. Place the smashed cloves inside the pumpkin/squash halves with your fresh thyme.

hands adding garlic cloves to a pumpkin half on a cutting board in kitchen

pumpkin half with garlic cloves and fresh thyme

Place a flat pan against the cut side of the squash before flipping the entire thing over, leaving the squash/pumpkin face down on the pan.

pumpkin half on a backing sheet in kitchen

Bake your squash halves at 375° for around 35-40 minutes, depending on size. Check it periodically for softness. If you desire, you can add a small amount of water to the pan in order to create some steam.

man placing baking pan with pumpkin half into oven

When you can press into the squash easily with a light touch, it's ready to come out of the oven.

cooked pumpkin half on a baking sheet

Loosen the squash from the pan by gently working a knife or small spatula underneath the edges.

removing pumpkin half from baking sheet with spatula and over mit

When you flip the squash over, the insides should be completely soft and moist.

Scoop the thyme and garlic cloves out of the squash. Deposit some of the thyme leaves along with the whole cloves of garlic and some of the liquid from inside the squash into the bottom of a blender.

using spoon to scoop spices and garlic from inside the pumpkin half on a baking pan

herbs and spices in a blender

Scrape the softened flesh of the squash into the blender.

hand with spoon scrapping inside from pumpkin half on baking pan

Add a small pad of butter (1-1 1/2 tablespoons).

pumpkin puree with butter pad in blender

Blend and stir periodically until well blended.

blender with pumpkin puree and hand pressing button

pumpkin puree in blender with steam rising

top view of pumpkin puree in blender

Add a small amount of cream along with salt to taste and blend until it reaches a smooth, creamy consistency.

milk in measuring cup on counter top with towel

hand pouring milk into blender with pumpkin puree using spoon and measuring cupt

Ta-da! A creamy, flavorful puree for your use. Add a little chicken or vegetable stock to make it into a soup, or use it as a topping for a meat dish.

pumpkin puree in pan with spoon top view

spices, herbs, garlic, butter, pumpkin halves and cooked pumpkin in pan on a counter top

This recipe is mainly for use directly after, though if you'd like to freeze it, simply omit the butter and cream and pack into freezer containers with a small amount of space left at the top for expansion. To use, defrost and blend together with the butter and small amount of cream or vegetable/chicken stock, and it will be ready to use once more.

Here's a little background on the pumpkin we used... the Winter Luxury pumpkin!
It is said to be the best pie pumpkin, ever! The vines produce medium sized, 5-7 pound tangerine orange pumpkins that are blanketed with white netting giving it a pastel appearance. The flesh is silky smooth with just the right amount of sweetness. A must have if you like to have your own canned pumpkin in the pantry. Introduced in 1893 by Johnson and Stokes of Philadelphia, also know as Livingston Pie Squash. One pumpkin averages 2 pies and one plant produces an average of 4 pumpkins that weigh 5-7 lbs.

NOTE: If you would like to can squash or pumpkin, a different method altogether is required. Instead of being pureed, canned pumpkin or squash must be cubed. See these instructions, sourced from the USDA.

Dried Pumpkin/Squash Instructions: Wash and dry pumpkin or squash, remove seeds, stringy flesh, and skin. Cut into small pieces, 1” wide by 1/8” thick strips. Blanch over steam for 3 minutes then dip into cold water to stop blanching action, drain excess moisture. Dry in electric dehydrator. You can also dehydrate in the oven on cookie sheet, placed on low/warm (140-150 degrees) with the door propped open to allow moisture to be removed for 10-16 hours. Grinf the dried pieces in a food processor and store in an airtight jar. To reconstitute, use 1 part pumpkin to 2 ½ part water.



Pumpkin and Squash Puree Recipe PDF

6 comments on Pinetree's Pumpkin & Squash Puree Recipe

  • Karen
    KarenNovember 11, 2021

    I used to add the thyme, garlic, butter after cooking during the blending process. This recipe is so very much better! Delicious flavor. My new and better way to cook squash and pumpkin. Much thanks.

  • Joyce Wood
    Joyce WoodNovember 11, 2021

    Thanks!! Great Idea – excited to try it. I usually boil the pumpkin/squash, season it and freeze it for later. Baking just seems so much healthier all around!!

  • Donna Childs
    Donna ChildsNovember 26, 2019

    Posting just in time for my Butternut squash Thanksgiving contribution. Nice cutting board, by the way.

  • Jan Taylor
    Jan TaylorNovember 26, 2019

    Great info – thank you! I especially liked the historical background and directions for drying pumpkin/ squash.

  • joan  jones
    joan jonesNovember 26, 2019

    thanks for the tip on dehydrating.!

  • 1 2 Next »

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published..



Your cart is currently empty.

Start Shopping

Select options